CONTACT CAROLINE
facebook
rss
tumblr
twitter
goodreads
youtube

  • Home
  • Write Away Blog
  • Books
    • Books
    • Trompe l’Oeil
    • Heart Land
    • Gothic Spring
    • Ballet Noir
    • Book Excerpts
  • Video Interviews
  • Press
    • News
    • Print Interviews
    • Plays
    • Ballet Noir in the Press
    • Trompe l’Oeil In The Press
    • Gothic Spring In The Press
    • Heart Land Reviews
  • Contact
  • About
  • Resources
    • Writer Resources
    • Favorite Blogs
    • Favorite Artists



The Unrepentant Critic

Nov 03, 2016
by Caroline Miller
Adam Johnson, caroline miller, Manners & Misdemeanors, Oscar Wilde, Pete Wells, Susan Stoner, the art of critiques, The Orphan Master's Son
0 Comment

A while ago, a theater critic wrote of a performance he’d endured, “Those of us who have witnessed the play… last night will undoubtedly hold periodic reunions In the noble tradition of survivors of the Titanic.” (“Manners & Misdemeanors,” by Pete Wells, Town&Country, November 2016, pg. 134.”)  A fine example of rapier wit that has a point.

As Pete Wells suggests in his recent essay, well written critiques aren’t rants.  If a rapier is required, it should make a clean thrust to the heart, not attempt a bloody bludgeoning. A good critique should avoid too much vitriol or surgery praise, if praise be warranted.  On either occasion, the critic should never “boil over into hysteria.” (Ibid pg. 132).  A little stretching of the truth.. some exaggeration is permitted, as in the Titanic example above.   Excess, however, is likely to make the reader or audience wonder whether or not the critic has lost his or her mind.  The goal, after all, “is to be believed.”  (Ibid pg. 134.)

the_orphan_masters_son_book_cover

Courtesy of wikipedia.com

Nearly two-and-a-half years ago, Susan Stoner, author of the historical Sage Adair mystery series, and I, writer of all trades, began our book review series, “Just Read It,” on YouTube.  (Sample)  Our first program discussed Adam Johnson’s, The Orphan Master’s Son. Though the book won awards and was highly praised by the literati,  neither my co-host, our guest nor I could find much merit in it and said so.  I may have seemed particularly harsh because a viewer rose to Johnson’s defense and, for a time, the two of us traded opinions.  During the exchange, I admit I was humbled by a few well-placed blows.  Perhaps I was obligated to find one kind word to say.  Perhaps I had given too much of the plot away.

Two-and-a-half years later, I remain chastened by that early criticism.  I hope our YouTube audience sees my improvement.   But I do not concur with the notion that I should find something nice to  remark upon for the sake of balance if no balance exists.

Oscar Wilde once said, “The job of a critic is to report to us on his moods.”  He’s right, of course.  A critic’s opinion is only that.  Still, where The Orphan Master’s Son is concerned, mine hasn’t changed.  If some similar Titanic group should emerge from among those who have read Johnson’s book,  I would be among the first to join.

 

 

 

Social Share

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

*
*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Contact Caroline at

carolinemiller11@yahoo.com

Portland, Oregon author Caroline Miller had distinguished careers as an educator, union president, elected official and artist/advocate.

Her play, Woman on the Scarlet Beast, was performed at the Post5 Theatre, Portland, OR, January/February 2015

Caroline published a serialized novelette, Marie Eau-Claire, on the website, The Colored Lens.  She also published the story Gustav Pavel,  a parable about ordinary lives, choice and alternate potential, on the website Fixional.co.

Caroline has published four novels

  • Ballet Noir
  • Trompe l’Oeil
  • Gothic Spring
  • Heart Land

Subscribe to Caroline’s Blog


 

Archives

Categories

YouTube-logo-inline2 To access and subscribe to my videos on YouTube, Click Here and click the Subscribe button.

Banner art “The Receptive” by Charlie White of Charlie White Studio

Web Admin: ThinPATH Systems, Inc
support@tp-sys.com

Subscribe to Caroline's Blog


 

Contact Caroline at

carolinemiller11@yahoo.com

Sitemap | Privacy Notice

AUDIO & VIDEO VAULT

View archives of Caroline’s audio and videos interviews.


Copyright © Books by Caroline Miller
Posting....