CONTACT CAROLINE
facebook
rss
tumblr
twitter
goodreads
youtube

  • Home
  • Write Away Blog
  • Books
    • Books
    • Trompe l’Oeil
    • Heart Land
    • Gothic Spring
    • Ballet Noir
    • Book Excerpts
  • Video Interviews
  • Press
    • News
    • Print Interviews
    • Plays
    • Ballet Noir in the Press
    • Trompe l’Oeil In The Press
    • Gothic Spring In The Press
    • Heart Land Reviews
  • Contact
  • About
  • Resources
    • Writer Resources
    • Favorite Blogs
    • Favorite Artists



Law And Order

May 29, 2015
by Caroline Miller
Is Shame Necessary?, Laura Kipnis, So You've Been Pullically Shamed, The Deep Dark Ugly Thing, the role of shame and guilt
2 Comments

In her review of two new books*, Laura Kipnis discusses the distinction between guilt and shame.  (“The Deep, Dark, Ugly Thing,” by Laura Kipnis,  Harper’s, May 2015, pg. 93)  Guilt is an internal standard of personal values. Shame results from a violation of group standards.  In the past, getting a divorce was shameful and until recently so was being a homosexual.  In the west today, neither status is a reason to hide in the closet.  The greatest shaming charge in modern times is of being a racist. (Ibid, pg. 93)

 Shame as a public reckoning is a specialty of the media, though it has become a tool of the internet, as well.  The difference between the two — media or the internet user —  is that the former have to be accountable for the facts made public.  If those facts are wrong — as they were in the case of The Rolling Stones magazine’s exposé about a gang rape at a fraternity house at the University of Virginia — the reporter and the organization which printed the story are liable for the misinformation.  Unfortunately,  Individuals who use the internet to shame others can hide behind false identities. 

In one of the books under review,  So You’ve Been Publically Shamed* by  Jon Ronson, the author speculates that many attackers have been publically shamed, themselves.  Someone exposed for animal abuse, for example, is likely to spread that shame to other abusers.  (Ibid pg. 92).  Jennifer Jacquet,  author of “Is Shame Necessary?*, takes a different view.  She supports shaming as non-violent resistance available to those who feel their values are under attack.  (Ibid pg. 92)

Of course, not everyone can be shamed.  After the 2009 financial crisis, few bankers came forward with a mea culpa.  Instead, they took their hefty salaries and stock options as if the money were a vote of confidence.

There a good reasons to consider the role of shaming in society, however.  The most important is whether or not we want any individual with a computer to sit in judgment on others?  As James Q. Whitman, a professor at the Yale law School has warned, “shaming transfers the power to punish from the state to the public where it risks becoming ‘fickle and uncontrolled.’” (Ibid 92-93.)

We’ve seen the consequences of trial by media and the frenzy of judgment it can produce.  The power of the internet can make that rush to judgment worse, and as  members of a civil society, we should be aware of that consequence.  The Greek philosopher Seneca once said,” Shame may restrain what law does not prohibit.”  That may be so.  But it is a dangerous tool in the 21st century.  Lives can be destroyed with an electronic whisper that leaves the victim with no place to hide for the rest of his or her life.   

man locked in the stocks

Courtesy of www.corbis.com

2 Comments
  1. S. L. Stoner May 29, 2015 at 10:15 am Reply
    It seems like the internet is functioning as the greatest equalizer humanity has ever seen. It will have both pitfalls and blessings. We humans will learn from them over time. I hope that the internet will enable humanity to develop a shared and compassionate set of values. But, hate-filled demagoguery remains a strong, countervailing force. Cautionary words like yours are a helpful contribution.
    • Caroline Miller May 29, 2015 at 2:20 pm Reply
      I'm inclined to believe the forces of compassion will prevail, but I've no doubt it's going to be a bumpy ride to get there.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

*
*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Contact Caroline at

carolinemiller11@yahoo.com

Portland, Oregon author Caroline Miller had distinguished careers as an educator, union president, elected official and artist/advocate.

Her play, Woman on the Scarlet Beast, was performed at the Post5 Theatre, Portland, OR, January/February 2015

Caroline published a serialized novelette, Marie Eau-Claire, on the website, The Colored Lens.  She also published the story Gustav Pavel,  a parable about ordinary lives, choice and alternate potential, on the website Fixional.co.

Caroline has published four novels

  • Ballet Noir
  • Trompe l’Oeil
  • Gothic Spring
  • Heart Land

Subscribe to Caroline’s Blog


 

Archives

Categories

YouTube-logo-inline2 To access and subscribe to my videos on YouTube, Click Here and click the Subscribe button.

Banner art “The Receptive” by Charlie White of Charlie White Studio

Web Admin: ThinPATH Systems, Inc
support@tp-sys.com

Subscribe to Caroline's Blog


 

Contact Caroline at

carolinemiller11@yahoo.com

Sitemap | Privacy Notice

AUDIO & VIDEO VAULT

View archives of Caroline’s audio and videos interviews.


Copyright © Books by Caroline Miller
Posting....